Hung

In Part 3 of the Meggan Sundwall case, Christie walks us through the defense’s strategy — reframing Kacee’s lies, fraud, and drug activity as evidence of suicide while questioning Meggan’s role in her death. The state counters with forensic experts, testimony from Kacee’s ex-husband, and an endocrinologist whose findings raise serious questions. Christie and Maryn weigh the evidence as the state rests and the defense prepares its final push.

In Part 2 of the Meggan Sundwall case, Christie digs into the digital evidence — and it’s damning. A forensic analysis of Meggan’s phone reveals a trail of searches, deletions, and a years-long text thread with Kacee that prosecutors say tells the whole story. This one’s a mega episode — because trust us, you’ll want every detail. Christie and Maryn wade through the messages and ask the question the jury will have to answer: was this a mercy — or a murder?

In Part 1 of the Meggan Sundwall case, Christie walks us through the trial of a Utah nurse charged with aggravated murder in the death of her friend Kacee Lynn Terry. The state alleges Meggan helped administer a fatal insulin overdose — all while expecting to collect a $1.5 million life insurance policy. The defense says the state can’t prove it wasn’t suicide. Christie and Maryn dig into the testimony, the texts, and a web of lies that goes deeper than anyone expected.

In the final installment of the Issiah Ross case, Maryn takes the lead as the verdict finally arrives — after four days of deliberations stretched out by a winter storm. She and Christie break down the evidence the jury leaned on, Ross’s background, his controversial post-incident SoundCloud uploads, and his mother’s Facebook Live reactions. They also discuss “Lyric and Devin’s Law,” new legislation prompted by the case. Was justice served? Maryn and Christie weigh in.

In Part 2 of the Issiah Ross case, Christie digs into the trial evidence — and the deeper she goes, the murkier the picture gets. Two sides. Two stories. And enough conflicting evidence to make anyone second-guess themselves. Will Maryn and Christie come out with a verdict? Or will this case be… Hung?

In January 2026, Issiah Ross stood trial for the September 2022 killings of 18-year-old Devin Clark and 14-year-old Lyric Woods — two teenagers found dead on a secluded service road in Mebane, North Carolina. The state says Ross lured them there under the guise of a sexual encounter, then shot them both and fled to Delaware. The defense tells a different story: that Devin shot Lyric first, turned the gun on Ross, and Ross fired back in self-defense. This week, Christie takes the lead as she walks us through the trial, and she and Maryn dig into the evidence to figure out what really happened that night.

Maryn and Christie break down the Tracey Nix case, starting with the unusual six-person jury and how that can shape deliberations. They walk through the trial, the verdict, and the judge’s reasoning at sentencing. The hosts also explore information the jury never heard—details that raise new questions about how the case might have been viewed if they had been allowed in court. The episode ends with a surprising development after the trial, including allegations that led to Nix being moved within the prison system.

Maryn and Christie break down the Florida trial of Tracey Nix. Tracey was charged with aggravated manslaughter after her seven-month-old granddaughter, Uriel Shock, died after being left in a car for nearly three hours. The episode examines agreed-upon facts, witness testimony, bodycam footage, and medical evidence, alongside the defense’s claim of tragic negligence versus the prosecution’s argument of culpable disregard. At the center of the case: Florida’s legal definition of culpable negligence—and how it shapes the verdict.

In the final episode of the Colin Griffith series, Maryn and Christie move from the courtroom to the court of public opinion, examining why many continue to believe he is guilty despite a not guilty verdict. The episode revisits Colin’s background, family instability, and domestic violence history, and explores the 2023 Oklahoma shooting death he reported as self-defense — a case investigators declined to pursue after stating they could not rule it out. The hosts also discuss what evidence was excluded at trial, how outside information could have shaped juror perception, and the difficult line between legal innocence and factual certainty. Maryn reads from an Oklahoma arrest-warrant affidavit describing alleged inconsistencies at the scene, raising questions about whether charges could ever be revisited.

In Part 3 of the Collin Griffith series, Maryn and Christie break down major courtroom testimony, starting with Collin’s grandfather, who claims Collin confided violent thoughts about killing Cathy and Susan—claims the defense challenges with phone records, shifting timelines, and questions about credibility. The hosts then analyze Ring audio and texts from the day Cathy died, highlighting her escalating, manipulative threats to family members. The episode covers the single defense witness, Susan Dethman (Collin’s grandmother), and Susan’s testimony about family dysfunction. Finally, they discuss closing arguments—describing the prosecutor’s emotional, graphic approach and the defense’s measured focus on reasonable doubt and potential self-defense—Find out Christie's verdict as the trial draws to a close.